Saturday, October 11, 2014

Speaking the Unspeakable: Sex Education
ARGUMENT
This writer states many valid and arguable points in this piece discussing the issues of gender identities in schools and places outside of school and how these places connect. The ideas of place and space, public and private and the combination of these is quite confusing because of the many topics that can relate to any of them. In this piece the argument was that place is neither a unitary experience nor a neutral stage upon which social relations are enacted. This means that the idea of place is always changing and it is based on the social relations that surround it. The argument is then reiterated at the end of the piece, "the public and private boundary appears to have a permeability that challenges the notion that sexuality is necessarily contained in one sphere or another, and the notion that there is indeed such a boundary despite the fact that our own perceived ‘private’ spaces can come to take on a material existence that we truly believe in, spaces can never really be fixed, for their boundaries are always open to continuous struggle and they are continually being made and remade through social relations". The process of bringing young children to the light of reality is not an easy process and there are many things that need to be taken into consideration before teachers begin forming lessons around those ideas and plans. Many teachers decided to come out to their children in the hope of making them more comfortable discussing it in the classroom and in turn discussing it at home as well. This is proof that the public space of school and the discussions that are based in school meld over into the private places of the students homes. Both public and private spaces go hand in hand and affect the other. This piece reminds me of the video we watched in class about the teachers introducing a day in the school that is dedicated to teaching children about the differences in sexuality. It was then melded into their home lives because they would ask their parents many questions about what the teacher had taught them in school. This can create controversy because the parents may not want the child to grow up thinking a certain way. The most amazing thing in the video was a little girl who was sitting with her two mothers looking so happy and comfortable in the classroom environment. This combines the home and school lives, public and private.

Points to bring up in class:
In the piece there was a lot of discussion about the staff room and how it becomes a more private place for the teachers to discuss issues but they are in a public place, the school still. I wonder, as a future teacher how I will react to such an environment and if I will face these decisions one day also. I would also like to talk to the parents in the classroom about how they plan, if they haven't already, to talk to their kids about gender identities in the public and private spaces.

I found an article describing a disorder that is Gender Dysphoria:
http://psychcentral.com/disorders/gender-dysphoria-symptoms/






6 comments:

  1. I really like your thoughts on what to bring up in class! I feel as though in the generation that we are living today and for our future children, society will be a bit more accepting then it is today. I feel as though it's not going to be taboo for teachers to talk about sexuality and LGBT type of subjects. The earlier you bring it up, the more open and willing children will be about not only talking about it but excepting it.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I also really like your points to bring up in class, honestly if you really think about how you would react to someone who tells you something about their sexuality most likely you will think you will support them no matter what their decision is. However that is not always the case people may act harshly towards that, and in a school environment every single person deserves to feel welcome. I always enjoy reading your thoughts.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I think the point you brought up about discussing the topic with the future parents of your students is important. As I was reading this piece I was really quite shocked that the teacher did not mention anything about discussing it with the parents of her students before showing her Cindy lesson. Especially when working with young children you have to be very careful that students don't go home and give their parents the wrong information about what happened in class that day. So i think your idea of discussing a plan with the parents before doing anything would be a really good idea!

    ReplyDelete
  4. I liked your ideas about how you would react when you become a teacher. Talking about LGBT in school is a way for the children to understand and talk about topics, that they may not be able to with their parents.

    ReplyDelete
  5. i agree with what your saying, but i think in the future it will be a lot more easy to talk about gays and lesbians in the classroom than it has been in the past. It is becoming much more accepted in society. So thats good.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I agree with what you said about both private and public space going hand in hand.I hope we get to discuss your points to bring up in class. I'm interested in hearing the responses.

    ReplyDelete